| APA | Vickers, P. (2020, December 02). Idealism, panpsychism and science.IAI News. /articles/idealism-panpsychism-and-science-auid-1700 | |
| MLA | Vickers, Peter. "Idealism, panpsychism and science." IAI News, 02 December 2020. /articles/idealism-panpsychism-and-science-auid-1700 |
Are philosophers of mind merely speculating?
Issue 93, 2nd December 2020
Peter Vickers
| Science-first philosopher at the University of Durham
2,921 words
Read time: approx. 15 mins
Philosopher of science Peter Vickers puts forward his take on the recent IAI News standoff between panpsychism and idealism.
It is absolutely accepted that the philosopher should have a great respect for science, as an epistemological endeavour. On the face of it, both science and philosophy search for truth: scientists ask ‘big’ questions such as “Where did human beings ultimately come from?”, and philosophers similarly ask ‘big’ questions such as “What is the relationship between the mind and the brain?”. But whereas scientists sometimes actually reach truth (human beings evolved from more primitive mammals, which themselves evolved from amphibians, etc.), philosophers seemingly never do, and are doomed to forever go round in circles.
Looking back at the history of philosophy, it is usual to speak of ‘fashions’; for example, when we ask about the relationship between mind and matter, there was a time when dualism was in fashion, a time when idealism was in fashion, and another time when physicalism was in fashion. More recently, panpsychism is enjoying a great deal of attention. But it would be bold indeed to claim that philosophers are on the way to definitively solving the mind-matter problem, in the way scientists have definitively solved a huge number of epistemological problems. Of course, some Kuhnians would try to push back, saying that science is punctuated by revolutions. But this is a fallacy: only radicals on the fringe think the evolutionary theory of mankind’s origins will one day be overturned in a Kuhnian revolution. Similarly, scientists really do know where stars come from, how viruses and bacteria cause illness, and a hundred other things. (Open questions concerning the details remain, naturally.)
Peter Vickers
Issue 93, 2nd December 2020
Continue reading
Enjoy unlimited access to the world's leading thinkers.
Start by exploring our subscription options or joining our mailing list today.
Start Free Trial
Already a subscriber?Log in
Related Videos
Join the conversation
Ry Suraski7 July 2024
Is metaphysics speculative????? If a bear sh*ts in the woods, does it make a sound?
"The reasons [to find panpsychism reasonable] are ‘philosophical’ and so of limited persuasive power". I mean, yes, in the sense that literally every belief, including that scientists exist, or that the world has existed for longer than one second, or the experiments of empirical science ever occurred, are ALL mere philosophical propositions. Tell me, in scientific terms: why are some unfalsifiable, non-empirical philosophical beliefs "more sciencey" than others? Because they're culturally popular right now? Metaphysics can only use so much science. The issue with these metaphysical worldviews isn't that they aren't "based enough in science" because they literally have the aim of accounting for modern physics generally. That cannot be done via science. It's not logically coherent. If you hold the only confirmed-real camera in the entire universe, would you say it's impossible to know whether cameras exist because so far there's been no direct photographic evidence?
This whole article is a strawman. Dismissing metaphysical perspectives for not being empirical is like dismissing psychotherapy for having practical aspects that predate/are not based on the principles of neuroscience, which would limit psychology to whatever neuroscience has and could achieve. Or maybe more like dismissing all ethics that aren't codified into law as invalid.
Nobody has claimed that metaphysical worldviews are "based in science"- they are interpretations of the science, just like physicalism (also 0% empirical). Is this a weird, long-winded proposal that the entire field of philosophy must present a disclaimer before every statement that defines what philosophy is and carefully explains that it is not a natural science...?
Pooja Sharma28 April 2023
Hi am pooja sharma accompanies relative which gives you best to best assistance with accompanies. Administration is constantly given on our site, at whatever point you need, you can get it on our site.
alisha kihn6 April 2023
hi
Linda Martin26 March 2022
I noticed that you’ll be are usually legitimately interested in this type of! We are seeking to build my own ring online site and you also include reduced the problem by including great statistics. Website Design Kamloops
Shreveport Masonry15 November 2021
Idealism has got to be where we are right now!
ida sanka2 September 2021
i really liked your article. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful post. pest control near me
killer smile2 September 2021
I really enjoyed reading your article. I found this as an informative and interesting post, so I think it is very useful and knowledgeable. Open here
killer smile2 September 2021
Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this.
bath remodeling amarillo
Breana Michael31 August 2021
Thanks for sharing this great article. kitchen remodel raleigh nc
Rip Dip29 August 2021
Each consumer is assigned a specific number on their credit report, coasttradelines.com which is known as a credit score.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
This innovative type of cement has all of the same physical attributes as traditional materials, www.cincinnaticoncretecontractorsco.com but its unique design can be customized in any number of ways.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
They're also incredibly tough when fully cured, www.lakelandconcretecontractors.com which means you'll never need more than one layer if you purchase from a reputable company like us, too!
Rip Dip29 August 2021
That’s why we offer competitive prices and value-packed services, www.charlestonroofingpros.com ensuring you won't find better options in any other local companies.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
Among our list of fencing services, www.themaconfencecompany.com chain link fencing is our most economical offering.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
We are proud to say that our people work day-by-day to ensure www.coralspringsdumpsterrentalco.com we got the most competitive prices in town. We guarantee our dumpster rental rates are affordable.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
They come in various sizes so you can be sure www.tallahasseedumpsterrentalco.com we have one depending on your need.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
More so, www.augustadumpsterrentalco.com we provide free cost estimates and consultations to help you make an informed decision.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
Whether you need new installation or repair of your current driveway, www.knoxvilleconcretecontractorsco.com you can count on us.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
They can replace your old or damaged roofing shingles, metal roof, www.knoxvilleroofingco.com or any material for that matter.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
This will help you clean up www.boyntonbeachdumpsterrental.com in a more efficient way.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
Are you looking for asphalt paving for your home www.stlucieasphaltpaving.com or a structure you want to construct?
Rip Dip29 August 2021
An ugly and deteriorating concrete driveway could put a potential buyer off of your property, www.stlucieconcretecontractors.com or embarrass you in front of family and friends.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
Needless to say, www.stluciepoolinstallers.com you can focus on more important things than this.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
You will not need to stress about doing the basem*nt finishing on your own, www.stluciekitchenremodeling.com and we can even install a basem*nt office for you if you would like.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
It will be automated as well, [url=http://www.stlucielandscaping.com]www.stlucielandscaping.com so you are not going to need to worry about trying to manage it in addition to your other commitments.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
A new roof installation project is a significant amount of work, www.rooferstamford.com and requires careful planning and design processes to be carried out before any physical work takes place.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
You may have guessed by now, www.bathroomremodelstamford.com but our team likes things that are a little bit fancy.
Rip Dip29 August 2021
[Sample](https://example.com/)
Rip Dip29 August 2021
"Sample":https://example.com/
Rip Dip25 August 2021
Newborns are always so nice, www.portlandbabyphotographer.com soft and cuddly.
Rip Dip24 August 2021
Whether you need your house painted or just want to get the paint off your deck, [url=http://www.fullertonhomepainters.com]www.fullertonhomepainters.com we have the solutions for you!
Rip Dip24 August 2021
Whether you need your house painted or just want to get the paint off your deck, <a href="https://www.fullertonhomepainters.com/">www.fullertonhomepainters.com</a> we have the solutions for you!
edgar roa5 August 2021
Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful info.
Spiral Staircases Newcastle
Horea Kaii3 August 2021
This question also gets me to think about what philosophers think too. This has gotten me.
Dayton criminal attorney
Madison Wilson30 July 2021
Idealism is a metaphysical ontology intended to answer what reality is, that is, the essential, underlying nature of existence; therefore, by definition, Idealism is not science. - San Antonio Tile Installation
alo max13 July 2021
Prices offered by our website is cheap as compare to any other csgo account selling website
csgo accounts
gta 5 modded accounts
buy valorant accounts
cheap rust account
alo max13 July 2021
nice post test
Wayne Ogilvie12 July 2021
Please let me know if you’re looking for an author for your site. You have some great posts, and I think I would be a good asset. Reach mere here https://www.fortcollinsdeckbuilders.com
bella rose7 July 2021
This is such a great blog. Thank you for sharing your talent with everyone. You are an inspiration.
https://poolbuildersnewcastle.com/
Duncan Hemsworth29 June 2021
https://www.winnipegpressurewashing.com/eavestrough-cleaning-winnipeg.html
Duncan Hemsworth29 June 2021
Definitely never thought of it like this before but sure deserves some research. [url=https://towingwinnipeg.com]https://towingwinnipeg.com
Markus Padilla28 June 2021
This discussion should be based only on confirmed facts, and not on philosophical speculation and scientific assumptions.
brown crystal17 June 2021
For me, philosophy is the best topic of all times. Septic Service Pittsburgh PA.
william pulley12 June 2021
Idealism, panpsychist and science is still a great topic
punta gorda roofers
Bobby Rencher9 June 2021
Thanks to Peter Vickers for the distinction. It was clearly explained. Carpet Cleaning Fort Mcmurray
Lucas Abbe4 June 2021
It's quite difficult to awaken from a state of non-awareness. The structure is all that exists in physics. It can explain biology, but there's one missing piece: consciousness.. Local Business Listings
Lucas Abbe4 June 2021
It's quite difficult to awaken from a state of non-consciousness. The structure is all there is to physics. It can explain biology, but there is one missing piece: consciousness. <a href="https://abizlisting.com/">Local Business Listings</a>
Bobby Rencher3 June 2021
The principles enumerated herein will depend on how one can interpret and apply them in life. Hello and thanks to those who will support credit repair miami.
Patsy Moore2 June 2021
Do your research at Google
Patsy Moore2 June 2021
Do your research at <a href="https://www.google.com">Google</a>
Markus Padilla2 June 2021
I believe we should not define consciousness, which is something that individuals are certain of, by theories about which we are not certain. (I mean, theories about which we can't be certain due to their nature.)
geometry dash28 May 2021
I'm so happy to be a part of this event. Learned a lot from the most influential people and brightest minds within the community as well as countless opportunities for networking, code sprints, and informal conversations.
geometry dash
Ryan Leonard4 May 2021
This is the kind of content I'm looking for, It encircles my curiosity and finds it really really interesting! I dreamed to become a psychiatrist.
Carter Julian28 March 2021
It is the dynamic process of science because science is growing day after day with the hard work of scientists who are working for it. The structures of https://artdaily.com/news/131321/Writing-as-a-kind-of-art#.X-HGWWgzaUm might get the importance. The scientists may think about it and make a search plan because it is possible to do it by heart.
Bob Edward27 March 2021
This article gives me peace of mind and i am impressed with the information. Thank you for sharing this mind-blowing info.
life coach
Bob Edward27 March 2021
This article gives me peace of mind and i am impressed with the information. Thank you for sharing this mind-blowing info.
<a href="https://www.saclifecoach.com/contact-us">life coach</a>
Joe Anderson19 March 2021
I learned a lot from this site. Perfect and detailed information about idealism. I'll definitely back here to read more articles after I fix my leaking roof.
Jane Jones 18 March 2021
I think this is one of the best source idealism plus science. I have found what I was looking for, this house movers Ottawa have all the services I need.
tetris game24 December 2020
Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared an informative and interesting blog post with people.
<a href="https://cookie-clicker.io/">cookie clicker</a>
goalken highlight19 December 2020
I really enjoyed this site. This is such a Great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. temple run 3
vicp8 December 2020
What this argument points to is the epistemic ontological explanatory gap "of" or The Hard Problem". To the idealist there is the appearance of fundamental mind or consciousness. To the biologist all cell functions are underlined by the physical laws of nature. To a neutral physicalist it should make no difference whether we name this mind consciousness physics....For the philosopher the highest domain above the mammalian brain which evolved to operate the most complex sensorimotor system in nature is the human brain and system of social interaction or human language. Languages which share and direct the inner brain states or how nature solved the other minds problem. For the philosopher this highest domain claims metaphysics as the gauntlets of speculation which he hurls down like Zeus at the scientists. The scientists and engineers deal in a world of convenient language and concepts which enable their work. Galileo, Newton, Hume and others may have freed the scientist from the world of an appeared supernatural of gods and spirits. A world of language which socialized and directed humans for centuries. Galileo may have tried to isolate science and free us from the gap by landing us in the gap. Inside the gap we watch those neurons fire under a microscope and like the computationalist theorize that a philosophical zombie or computer can perform the same mind function without experience. Galileo may have solved a tree falling in the forest and nobody hears it, but what if the forest burned and nobody entered, would they feel heat? Heat and energy can be dismissed as Hume's billiard balls or neurons acquiring unique physical states by precise molecular interactions. The highest state of nature or consciousness as the lowest entropy organized states or informational states....fundamental feelings in organisms of hot and cold which evolve into higher mammals with multilayered neocortical structures which can extract metadata or metalanguage from more fundamental states.
Johnny O'Neill7 December 2020
Without diving into the validity of panpsychism, I would point out that, as far as the ‘a tree falling in the forest’ thought experiment, a conclusion stating that since no one was there to experience ‘sound’ there then was no ‘sound,’ but only vibrating air, is logically incorrect for the simple reason that by that logic, there was no tree that fell, either, and indeed, no forest which contained a tree. If no experience of sound, no sound; if no experience of electromagnetic light waves, no sight. Indeed, the basis of the thought experiment itself is only valid if we assume an objective reality existing independently of experience, and which admits of the falling tree making a ‘sound,’ such assumption thus rendering the question itself moot.
Taking that further, Schrödinger's famous cat in the box thought experiment is the same thought experiment as the tree in a forest. If there is a cat in a box (the falling tree) that no one can see or hear or directly experience, is it alive (meowing)?
Lacking experience of the cat, there is no ‘cat in a box,’ so again, it’s a moot question. The experience of a ‘cat in a box’ is, at best, the memory of a cat being placed in a box. It’s analogous to René Magritte’s famous painting of a pipe with the words, ‘This is not a pipe,’ painted underneath the ‘pipe.’
It’s a painting, not a ‘pipe.’ It’s a memory of a cat, not a ‘cat.’ It’s the assumption that a tree is falling, somewhere, not a ‘falling tree.’
While questions such as ‘is it a pipe’ are curiosities in our everyday dealings, when applied to things like the interactions of subatomic particles, they can be of profound importance. What is ‘it’ that we are actually ‘experiencing’? ‘Subatomic particles’? Or, perhaps, “an ‘awareness’ of what is ‘termed’ an ‘interaction’ ‘between’ what we ‘call’‘subatomic particles’”? Or, perhaps, some ’thing’ else entirely…?
Hugh Manbeing6 December 2020
.... I mean, let's face it, when you leave university with your philosophy degree, you've acquired the wisdom that the Marxists, the right wing press and the home secretary will allow you to have - and I don't think these people really know what the depths of human wisdom are.
For really exploring philosophy, there were better universities in India a thousand years ago. £27,000 for a modern philosophy degree - when there are mushrooms growing all over for free ? No thanks :-)
Vyacheslav Dianov5 December 2020
Too much confusion and idle talk.
This discussion should be based only on confirmed facts, and not on philosophical speculation and scientific assumptions.
I suggest starting the discussion with the fundamental question - is the world objective or not?
This question raises the need for a rational explanation of the spirit world. Does the spirit, the soul really exist or not?
Hugh Manbeing5 December 2020
....I should add that the relevance of extreme happiness is that it often is an aspect of non-dual experiences, but not always. Either way, if you were to survey scientists compared to people declaring an interest in non-duality or psychedelics, I think you would, generally, find a difference in depth of wellbeing both experienced and sought. A hunch.
Hugh Manbeing4 December 2020
When they teach exploration of, and experimentation in, non-dual experience in universities we may get some clarity on these matters.
Hugh Manbeing4 December 2020
...in fact, in this matter, academics have been hobbled by the superstitious prohibition on psychedelics and a cultural prejudice against extreme happiness, and so what we really have is a politically correct, socially obedient version of science and philosophy, with the real business being conducted off campus.
Ethan Bills4 December 2020
Given the job of science - i.e., understanding the objective causal properties of physical systems - science is, by definition, not metaphysics. Indeed, unlike science, Idealism is a metaphysical ontology intended to answer what reality is, that is, the essential, underlying nature of existence; therefore, by definition, Idealism is not science. Peter, instead of merely dismissing Bernardos views and calling them unscientific, how about you actually address them based on their philosophical merit. From what I can tell, Idealism is by far the most parsimonious, explanatory description of reality, especially when considering that Physicalism can't answer for the sole datum of existence itself - phenomenal consciousness - and to survive as an accurate ontological description of reality must postulate an infinite multiverse. Perhaps it's time for you to take these views a little more seriously.
Vic P3 December 2020
Very good article. I think what underscores the idealist and panpsychist position is a starting point. What "really" needs to be done is refine mind and consciousness as the reality problem. If in reality mind and consciousness exist at the levels of panpsychism or idealism, then how do our minds create our reality at this scale of objects, space, time, feelings, smell, sight....The physicalist approach may yield the proper data but the gap to explain this scaled reality still points towards the panpsychist idealist.
